Photo 1 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 2 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 3 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 4 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 5 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 6 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 7 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 8 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 9 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 10 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 11 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 12 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 13 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 14 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 15 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 16 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 17 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 18 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 19 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 20 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 21 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 22 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 23 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 24 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 25 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house
Photo 26 of 26 of 1724 Prospect Street house

Debbie McMillan · eXp Realty LLC

  • Overview

  • Monthly cost

  • Get pre-approved

  • Sales & tax history

  • Schools

  • Fees & commissions

  • Related

  • Intelligence reports

Save

Active

Buy a houseat 1724 Prospect Street, Indianapolis, IN 46203

$425,000

$430,000 (-1.16%)

Residential

1,748 Sq. Ft.

5,619 Sq. Ft. lot

4 Bedrooms

4 Bathrooms

283 Days on market

21987541 MLS ID

Click to interact

Property position on map

Click the map to interact

Intelligence

Investor Highlights
Price per square foot history
Property sales history

Subscribe to Intelligence

Discover advanced property insights, stats and many more.

Learn More

About 1724 Prospect Street house

Don't miss this opportunity to discover the best of Arts and Craftsman charm in the heart of Indianapolis. This "turn-of-the-century" 4 bedroom 3.5 bath home, was meticulously restored and renovated in 2018. Perfectly located steps away from Fountain Square so you can easily enjoy the vibrant heart of downtown Indy year round. This home is an exceptional blend of historic charm and modern convenience. The classic covered porch welcomes guests into the open-concept main level with bamboo floors and an eye-catching contemporary staircase. Designed for easy entertaining, the living room overlooks a breathtaking chef-inspired kitchen with an upscale farm sink, granite counters, subway-tiled backsplashes, and a large bar. This home boasts of 2 primary bedroom suites with fabulous ensuite bathrooms. One tucked away on the main level and the other upstairs. You'll love how this home blends today's trends and character with original features tastefully preserved alongside its contemporary upgrades. Walk up the striking statement stairway to discover vaulted ceilings, and a sprawling back deck overlooking a fenced yard dotted with mature trees-creating an ideal urban retreat. Practical amenities include dual furnaces/AC units, energy-efficient spray foam insulation, and an oversized 2-car garage, ensuring comfort and sustainability year-round. Whether unwinding in the luxurious soaker tub or exploring the cultural delights of downtown Indy, this home promises a lifestyle where historic elegance meets vibrant city living. Don't miss your chance to call this meticulously crafted residence your own-schedule your visit today
Don't miss this opportunity to discover the best of Arts and Craftsman charm in the heart of Indianapolis. This "turn-of-the-century" 4 bedroom 3.5 bath home, was meticulously restored and renovated in 2018. Perfectly located steps away from Fountain Square so you can easily enjoy the vibrant heart of downtown Indy year round. This home is an exceptional blend of historic charm and modern convenience. The classic covered porch welcomes guests into the open-concept main level with bamboo floors and an eye-catching contemporary staircase. Designed for easy entertaining, the living room overlooks a breathtaking chef-inspired kitchen with an upscale farm sink, granite counters, subway-tiled backsplashes, and a large bar. This home boasts of 2 primary bedroom suites with fabulous ensuite bathrooms. One tucked away on the main level and the other upstairs. You'll love how this home blends today's trends and character with original features tastefully preserved alongside its contemporary upgrades. Walk up the striking statement stairway to discover vaulted ceilings, and a sprawling back deck overlooking a fenced yard dotted with mature trees-creating an ideal urban retreat. Practical amenities include dual furnaces/AC units, energy-efficient spray foam insulation, and an oversized 2-car garage, ensuring comfort and sustainability year-round. Whether unwinding in the luxurious soaker tub or exploring the cultural delights of downtown Indy, this home promises a lifestyle where historic elegance meets vibrant city living. Don't miss your chance to call this meticulously crafted residence your own-schedule your visit today

Property details

Appliances

Dishwasher

Disposal

Electric Oven

Refrigerator

Electric Water Heater

Basement

Unfinished

Construction materials

Wood Siding

Current financing

Conventional

Electric

200+ Amp Service

Flooring

Hardwood

Foundation details

Block

Heating

Forced Air

Electric

Horse amenities

None

Interior features

Vaulted Ceiling(s)

Breakfast Bar

Laundry features

Main Level

Levels

Two

Parking features

Garage Door Opener

Detached

Patio and porch features

Covered

Property condition

Updated/Remodeled

Syndicate to

Homes.com

Realtor.com

Utilities

Cable Available

Electricity Connected

Monthly cost

Estimated monthly cost

$2,740/mo

All calculations are estimates and provided by Unreal Estate, Inc. for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.

Sale and tax history

Sales history

Date

Oct 5, 2023

Price

-

DatePrice
Oct 5, 2023-

Schools

This home is within the Indianapolis Public Schools & Purdue Polytechnic High School Independent.

Indianapolis enrollment policy is not based solely on geography. Please check the school district website to see all schools serving this home.

Public schools

D+

Francis Parker Montessori School 56

2353 Columbia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205

Student population: 346

School type: Elementary School, Middle School

B-

William Mckinley Elementary School 39

1733 Spann Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203

Student population: 415

School type: Elementary School

C+

Center For Inquiry School 2

725 N New Jersey St, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Student population: 438

School type: Elementary School, Middle School

C-

Longfellow Stem Magnet Middle School

510 Laurel St, Indianapolis, IN 46203

Student population: 452

School type: Middle School

D+

Arsenal Technical High School

1500 E Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN 46201

Student population: 2103

School type: High School

D+

Ips Butler University Laboratory School 55

1349 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Student population: 418

School type: Elementary School, Middle School

D-

Purdue Polytechnic High School

525 S Meridian St Ste Lla, Indianapolis, IN 46225

Student population: 543

School type: High School

D

Shortridge High School

3401 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46208

Student population: 1077

School type: High School

D

George Washington High School

2215 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46222

Student population: 798

School type: High School

D+

Crispus Attucks High School

1140 Dr Martin Luther King Jr St, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Student population: 1157

School type: High School

C

Arlington Middle School

120 E Walnut St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

Student population: 435

School type: Middle School

-

Francis Bellamy Pre-school Center 102

9501 E 36th Pl, Indianapolis, IN 46235

Student population: 72

School type:

Private schools

Seller fees & commissions

Home sale price

$

Outstanding mortgage

$

Selling with traditional agent

Selling with Unreal Estate agent

Your total sale proceeds$399,500

+$12,750

$412,250

Seller agent commission$12,750 (3%)*

$0 (0%)

Buyer agent commission$12,750 (3%)*

$12,750 (3%)*

*Commissions are based on national averages and not intended to represent actual commissions of this property All calculations are estimates and provided by Unreal Estate, Inc. for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.

Get $12,750 more selling your home
with an Unreal Estate agent

Start free MLS listing

Unreal Estate checked: Sep 10, 2024 at 1:32 p.m.

Data updated: Aug 23, 2024 at 4:36 p.m.

Courtesy of eXp Realty LLC.
Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed.
Listing Information © 2025 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. All Rights Reserved.

Learn more about this property

Request edits for this property

By proceeding, you consent to receive calls and texts at the number you provided, including marketing by autodialer and prerecorded and artificial voice, and email, from unrealestate.com and others about your inquiry and other home related matters, but not as a condition of any purchase.
*By checking this box, I confirm that I am the legal owner of the property listed. Please note, all information is verified for accuracy per U.S. real estate regulations, and submissions from non-owners cannot be processed.

Updated January 2023: By using this website, you agree to our Terms of Service, and Privacy Policy.

⁠Unreal Estate holds real estate brokerage licenses under the following names in multiple states and locations:
Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a USRealty.com, LLP)
Unreal Estate LLC (f/k/a USRealty Brokerage Solutions, LLP)
Unreal Estate Brokerage LLC
Unreal Estate Inc. (f/k/a Abode Technologies, Inc. (dba USRealty.com))
Main Office Location: 991 Hwy 22, Ste. 200, Bridgewater, NJ 08807
California DRE #01527504
New York § 442-H Standard Operating Procedures
TREC: Info About Brokerage ServicesConsumer Protection Notice

UNREAL ESTATE IS COMMITTED TO AND ABIDES BY THE FAIR HOUSING ACT AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY ACT.

If you are using a screen reader, or having trouble reading this website, please call Unreal Estate Customer Support for help at 1-866-534-3726 
Open Monday – Friday 9:00 – 5:00 EST with the exception of holidays.

*See Terms of Service for details.

LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon

© 2023 Unreal Estate Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Unreal Estate certified trust badge
LinkedIn Social IconInstagram social iconFacebook social icontwitter social iconYoutube Social Icon